Appeal Rulling #78A: 20 December 2023

169 downloads

Download (pdf, 741 KB)

CPEC-78A-20122023.pdf

An engineer (Engineer A) appealed two decisions of a Chair of Investigating  Committees (CIC).  Decision 1 concerned a complaint about Engineer A by another engineer (Engineer B) and Decision 2 concerned a counter-complaint by Engineer A against Engineer B.  In Decision 1 the CIC upheld the complaint, referring the matter to an investigating committee for further investigation.  In Decision 2 the CIC dismissed the counter complaint.  The appellant sought the overturning of both decisions.  Both complaints involved differing technical views on seismic assessments and strengthening design work associated with commercial buildings.